Hi Quinn B.
from what I see here, on first click, the modal opens well, on second click, the vertical positioning is off
you can fix that using the Contact modal 1 (Close) animation
also for the modal opening wrongly, you can change the affected elements for
Contact modal 1 (Open) animation from:
All elements with this class to
Only Siblings with this class
Contact modal 1 (Close) animation from:
All elements with this class to
Only parents with this class
videos attached